Electronics
Which Amazon Echo, Fire tablet or Fire TV device fits your home?
Pick between the Echo Dot, Show 5, Spot, Fire HD 8, Fire TV Cube and Voice Remote Pro by deciding what the device needs to do and where it sits.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure
It depends on the room and the job, not on the lineup. The Echo Dot is the sensible first buy for a bedroom, dining room or home office, and the Show 5, Spot, Fire HD 8 and Fire TV Cube earn their higher prices only if you can name the shelf, nightstand or couch they'll live on. If you can't, buy nothing yet.
Put the three Echo devices side by side on Amazon and they look like one product in three bodies. All three run Alexa, play Spotify and Apple Music, and can trigger routines that switch on compatible lights. Add a tablet, a streaming cube and a remote, and the whole page starts to feel like one long upsell.
It isn't, quite. Each of these solves a different problem, and three questions sort them out: whether you need a screen, whether the living room needs new hardware or just a better remote, and what you'd actually use a tablet for.
Do you need a screen? That is the real question between a Dot and a Show 5
Start with the Dot, because it's the baseline everything else has to beat. It has no screen, so you get no visible timers, no song titles and no camera feed. You hear everything and see nothing. What you get is Alexa, Bluetooth, the major music services, and built-in motion and indoor temperature sensors that can run routines: lights on when you walk in, a fan on when the room warms up. It also has the largest and most positive base of owner reviews of the six products here.
One feature is narrower than it sounds. The Dot can act as a mesh wifi extender, adding up to 1,000 sq. ft., but only to an existing eero network. If your router is anything else, that line on the listing does nothing for you.
The Show 5 costs more than the Dot, and the extra is worth paying only if you'll actually look at the screen every day. Three jobs justify it. The first is video calls with a relative who has the Alexa app or an Echo with a screen, using the 2 MP camera. The second is a photo slideshow when it's idle. The third is a glance at a compatible video doorbell while your hands are busy in the kitchen.
At 5.5 inches it's a glance device, though. A recipe read from across a counter means small text, and anything longer than a clip gets tiring to watch.
Owner feedback on it is more mixed than for the others. That doesn't make it a bad product, but it's a reason to sort the reviews on the page by critical before you order. The built-in shutter and the camera-off button help, but if the device is going in a bedroom, a camera is the wrong thing to add. Buy the Dot there.
The Spot is the hardest of the three to justify. It usually costs more than both the Dot and the Show 5, and the listing doesn't mention a camera. If you want video calling, the Show 5 is the one to look at. What the Spot adds is a clock face you can customize, song titles on screen, and a wake-up routine that pairs music with gradually brightening light.
If your phone already wakes you reliably and you don't mind it on the nightstand, you'd mostly be paying for a nicer view of the time. If you're trying to get the phone out of the bedroom, the Spot makes sense. One thing to check before you commit: a lit display in a dark room bothers some sleepers, so read the listing's details on dimming first. It has the same eero extender feature as the Dot.
The rule of thumb: pay for a screen only where you'd glance at it at least once a day, such as a kitchen counter or a desk where you take calls. For bedrooms, dining rooms and offices where you mostly want music and a voice, the Dot does the job. The Spot is for the person who wants a bedside clock and a phone-free night. The Show 5 is for the person whose family calls them on video.
Living room: a streaming cube or a better remote?
The Fire TV Cube costs many times what the Voice Remote Pro does, and they solve different annoyances. The Cube is a streaming player: 4K Ultra HD over Wi-Fi 6E, with hands-free Alexa so you can ask for a show from across the room without lifting a remote. The Remote Pro is an upgrade for a Fire TV device you already own.
Be honest about which problem you have. If your current Fire TV stick is slow and you're still on a 1080p TV, the Cube's headline specs won't help you much. You need a 4K TV to see 4K, and Wi-Fi 6E only pays off with a router that supports it. If you have a 4K TV, an older and sluggish player, and you'd actually talk to your TV, the Cube is a real upgrade.
Weigh the price against what you'd actually gain. The Cube is one of the pricier devices here, and Amazon's streaming hardware often goes on sale around big shopping events, so if your current player still works, there's little reason to buy it at full price. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide.
The Remote Pro is the better buy for a lot of households. It goes after one specific irritation: a remote that vanishes into the couch. Say "Alexa, find my remote" and it rings, provided you have an Alexa device, the Alexa app or the Fire TV app nearby. It also has TV power and volume controls, dedicated channel buttons for live TV, and a headphone button if you watch late with Bluetooth headphones.
Its limitation is a long compatibility exclusion list. It won't work with the first- and second-generation Fire TV, the first-generation Fire TV Stick, Element Fire TV Edition sets, Insignia HD and FHD models, the Hisense U6HF Fire TV series, or the Echo Show 15. It also does nothing for a Roku or Apple TV.
The pairing logic is simple. No Fire TV at all, or an old one that stutters: consider the Cube. A working Fire TV that you just keep misplacing the remote for: get the Remote Pro and stop there.
The tablet question: what will you use it for?
The Fire HD 8 has an 8-inch HD screen, 4GB of memory and 64GB of storage. That 64GB is the figure that matters if you plan to download shows for a flight or a week without wifi, since a handful of HD episodes eat storage fast. It's a couch-and-bed device. If you'd mostly use it for streaming and ebooks, it fits.
It's not a gaming tablet, and an HD panel at 8 inches won't look as sharp as a recent phone, which matters if you read small print for long stretches. Fire tablets also run Amazon's own software with its own app store, so some apps you'd find elsewhere may not be there. If your phone already has a 6.5-inch screen and you mostly watch on it, an 8-inch tablet adds less than you'd expect.
Amazon's own devices go on sale often, so compare the current price on Amazon with the list price shown there before you buy, and don't treat the list price as what you should pay.
All six side by side
| Product | Best for | Key spec | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Echo Dot Smart Speaker with Alexa | Bedroom, dining room or office music and routines | Motion and temperature sensors, no screen | No screen; the eero extender only helps an existing eero network |
| Amazon Echo Show 5 Smart Display | Video calls and a kitchen or desk glance screen | 5.5-inch display, 2 MP camera | Small screen, and more mixed owner reviews than the others |
| Amazon Echo Spot Smart Alarm Clock | A phone-free nightstand | Customizable clock display, wake-up routine with gradual light | Costs more than the Show 5 and no camera is listed |
| Amazon Fire HD 8 Tablet, 64GB | Couch, bed and travel streaming | 4GB memory, 64GB storage | Not as sharp as a recent phone; Amazon's own app store |
| Amazon Fire TV Cube Hands-Free 4K Streaming Device | Replacing a slow streamer in a 4K living room | 4K Ultra HD, Wi-Fi 6E | One of the pricier picks; only pays off with a 4K TV |
| Amazon Alexa Voice Remote Pro for Fire TV | Anyone who loses the remote | Remote finder, backlit buttons | A long list of incompatible Fire TV models |
Check this on the Amazon page before you order
Scroll to the compatibility information and match it against what you already own. That one step catches most of the mistakes in this guide. The Remote Pro has an explicit list of Fire TV models it won't work with, and a remote that doesn't pair means a return. The Dot's and Spot's mesh feature only works with eero, so if you're counting on it to fix a dead spot, confirm your router first. If you're buying a Cube, check that your TV is 4K before you pay for the extra resolution.
This guide can't tell you what only you know: whether your router is eero, which Fire TV model you have, or whether you'll look at a screen daily or ignore it after a week.
Get DealStoker picks by email
New buying guides and products worth a look, sent from time to time. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
New: sign up and we'll mail you 2 free DealStoker pens (96 left).We only use your email for the newsletter. Privacy