Electronics
Which noise cancelling headphones are worth the money for you?
Five headphones and earbuds, matched to a commute, a flight, a desk or a gym bag, plus which specs you can ignore and when to hold off.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure
For most people, the Soundcore Q20i is the pair worth buying. It's the budget over-ear pick here, it has real noise cancelling, and it has by far the largest base of owner reviews of the over-ear pairs here. The other four earn a spot only in narrower situations, like hands-free video, a gym bag, or a desk with a laptop and a phone. Two of them, the TOZO A1 and the AKG Y500, don't list noise cancelling in the product data we have, so treat them as alternatives rather than quiet-makers.
Over-ear or earbuds? Settle that first
Noise cancelling works by listening to the room through small microphones and playing an opposite signal. It's best on steady, low drones: a jet engine, a train's rumble, an air conditioner. It's weak on voices, station announcements and keyboard clatter, so nobody should expect silence from any pair here.
Over-ear cups add a physical barrier on top of the electronics, so they usually quiet a room more than earbuds do. Earbuds depend on a good seal from the ear tip and on how well the case fits in your life. A case slips into a jeans pocket. Over-ear headphones need space in a bag and sit warm on your head in July.
If a 45-minute rumbling train ride is the problem, lean over-ear. If you need something for the gym, for walks, or to keep in a coat pocket, go with earbuds and accept a smaller drop in noise.
A daily bus or train commute: the Soundcore Q20i
Take a commute of 90 minutes each way. That's three hours a day, and a 40-hour battery with noise cancelling on covers roughly 13 workdays before you reach for a cable. That kind of gap between charges is what you actually notice after a month.
Don't read the struck-through list price on Amazon as proof of a discount. Check the current price on Amazon and judge it against what you'd pay for other budget noise-cancelling headphones.
The limitation is simple. At this price the cancelling softens engine and tire rumble, but it doesn't erase it, and it won't match headphones that cost several times more. The cups are also bulky. If your bag is already full, or you can't stand pressure around your ears, move on to the P30i below.
Long flights, or a desk with a laptop and a phone: the Edifier W820NB Plus Gen 2
An 88-hour battery is enough for a dozen 7-hour flights before you plug in. For a work-from-home setup, the multipoint feature is the useful part. Your headphones stay paired to your laptop for video calls and your phone for everything else, without you re-pairing each time.
LDAC, the high-bitrate codec in the listing, only helps if your phone supports it, which many Android phones do. iPhones don't. If you're on an iPhone, ignore that line and weigh the pair on battery, multipoint and price alone.
Now the catch. It has far fewer owner reviews than the Q20i, so there's much less evidence behind it. Its price on Amazon also moves around, so check it before you order.
If you need those two features, this is a reasonable step up from the Q20i. If you don't, you'd be paying more for features you may never use.
Watching video on a plane, train or hotel bed: the Soundcore P30i
The case that folds into a phone stand is the detail to build a decision around. Prop your phone on a tray table or a hotel nightstand and you have a screen and sound without holding anything. If you watch episodes on trips, that's more useful than it sounds.
The 45 hours of playtime counts the charging case's extra charges. The earbuds alone will run for far fewer hours per charge, and the listing is where to check that figure. If you leave the case at home, you lose most of that battery.
It's also the budget way here to get noise cancelling in a pocketable form, so don't be swayed by the struck-through list price; check the current price on Amazon.
Two downsides. Earbud cancelling takes the edge off a low rumble but won't match over-ears on a loud flight. And IP54 means splash and dust resistance. A drizzly walk is fine, but don't rinse them under a tap.
Gym sessions, runs and rain: the TOZO A1
These are the budget pair here, and they're among the most-reviewed earbuds on Amazon. The IPX5 rating means they can handle sweat and water splashes from any direction. That makes them a sensible gym-bag pair, or a first pair of earbuds for a teenager who loses things.
They don't list noise cancelling, though. On a train, or in an open office with a loud coworker, they won't quiet anything beyond what the ear tip blocks physically. The listing's 32 EQ presets and AI call microphones are nice extras. They aren't a reason to pick these over a pair that actually cancels noise.
The data also doesn't say how many hours the earbuds run per charge. Check the listing before you count on a full day of use.
The AKG Y500: only if you specifically want it
This is the hardest one to recommend. It has only a small number of owner reviews so far, and it usually costs well more than the Q20i without a noise cancelling feature in the data.
On-ear pads sit on your ears instead of around them. Some people find that comfortable for hours, and others feel the pressure after an hour or so, especially with glasses. It's also a "US Version" listing, so check that it matches what you expect before ordering.
The case for it: you want a light, foldable on-ear set, you like the pink finish, and you listen in quiet places where cancelling isn't needed. If that's you, go ahead. If not, the Q20i does more for much less.
What isn't worth paying extra for
Decibel claims. The Edifier lists -49 dB of cancelling. That's a manufacturer figure, and brands measure it differently, so you can't compare it to another brand's number. Treat it as marketing.
Bluetooth version. The listings range from 5.3 to 6.1. For music, calls and video the difference in daily use is tiny. A pair with 5.3 and a better fit beats one with 6.1 and a bad fit.
Hi-Res and LDAC. These need a compatible phone and compatible source files. On a noisy bus, you're unlikely to hear the difference even if you have both. Pay for them only if you listen at home with a good source.
Spatial sound and app extras. EQ presets, spatial modes and custom controls get tried a couple of times and then forgotten. Battery and fit are what you live with every day.
Color. Pink, black and smoky pink cost the same as the other finishes on the same model, so pick the one you like and don't let it decide the model.
A big list-price discount. A struck-through list price says little about what people actually pay. Compare the current price with similar headphones, not with the strike-through.
Your next step
Decide on over-ear or earbuds first. If it's over-ear, the Q20i is the order to place. If it's earbuds and you want cancelling, the P30i is the one to look at.
Wear whichever pair you buy for a full two hours in real noise on the first day, and keep an eye on the return window on the Amazon listing while you do. No review, including ours, can tell you how a headband or ear tip feels on your head, or whether you have glasses that clash with on-ear pads. We haven't tested any of these, so that part is yours to judge.
If the Edifier is the one you want, check its current price on Amazon before you order; there's no rush on a desk headset.
Get DealStoker picks by email
New buying guides and products worth a look, sent from time to time. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
New: sign up and we'll mail you 2 free DealStoker pens (96 left).We only use your email for the newsletter. Privacy